In a recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision, the court upheld a lower court finding that the son of a woman with Alzheimer’s was a vexatious litigant and did not have standing to object to the passing of accounts in the administration of the mother’s property.
The mother was 92 years of age and suffers from Alzheimer’s disease. She lived in her own home under the care of her daughter, who was her guardian for personal care.
The mother also had three sons: Michael, Peter and Andrew.
Michael was her litigation guardian and, jointly with the daughter, was also her guardian for personal care.
The mother’s guardian for property was the BMO Trust Company.
The guardianship appointments had been made under the Substitute Decisions Act, 1992 in 2015. As part of the original court order, BMO Trust had been required to pass its accounts in respect of the administration of the mother’s property for the period April 29, 2015 to June 25, 2017.
However, the passing of accounts for this period had not taken place, primarily because the daughter and Peter had appealed the appointment of BMO Trust. The daughter and Peter contended that they should have been appointed guardians of the mother’s property. The appeal made it all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada and was dismissed in 2018.
After the Supreme Court of Canada judgment, Peter again sought to have BMO Trust removed as guardian of property and to have Michael removed as the litigation guardian. He raised allegations of collusion, conspiracy and an alleged secret agreement between Michael and BMO Trust, though he did not file any evidence in support of the allegations.
In response, Michael submitted that Peter was a vexatious litigant in the proceedings and was engaging in a bad faith attempt to re-litigate matters already determined by the Court of Appeal.
Lower Court Decision
The lower court rejected Peter’s claim, stating:
“In my view, the [Michael]’s position is correct and the arguments [Peter] seeks to advance on this passing of accounts is an abuse of process which can only have the effect of turning what should be a simple accounting and oversight exercise into a lengthy and unproductive re-litigation of positions previously rejected by the court. […]
It is also intolerable that a person appearing in a proceeding such as this can be permitted to put forward allegations of conspiracy, an undisclosed litigation agreement, criminality and breach of trust without a shred of evidence to support such allegations and without providing an affidavit setting out these allegations.”
As a result, the court ordered that Peter would not be accorded standing in the passing of accounts on the basis that he was a vexatious litigant and the court struck out his notice of objection.
Peter appealed the decision.
Court of Appeal Decision
The Court of Appeal began by stating:
“We find it unnecessary to deal with [Peter]’s submissions that, as a beneficiary under the will of the incapable [mother], he had the right to standing in the passing of accounts. While the motion judge expressed the view [Peter] required leave to participate, the primary basis of his decision is that [Peter] is a vexatious litigant.”
The court found that the record provided ample support for the motion judge’s findings.
The appeal was dismissed.
We are committed to the health and safety of our community and helping ‘flatten the COVID-19 curve’. Our office remains open, but for the health and safety of all members of our community we will be limiting in-person client engagements in our office until further notice.
Your matters are extremely important to us and we want to assure you that business will not be disrupted.
If you have any questions we encourage you to contact us at email@example.com. Let’s continue to take care of each other during this difficult time.
The knowledgeable estate lawyers at Cherkowski Marsden LLP have over 50 years of combined experience helping people in Vernon create Wills designed to protect their families’ futures. Everyone, no matter their stage in life or income bracket, should have a Will to retain control over the administration of their estate. We work with clients with both modest and robust estate planning needs, advising on matters including asset distribution, business considerations, foreign assets and trust considerations. For clients with business assets and those in need of assistance with succession planning, we also offer the benefit of our considerable business law experience. It is impossible to predict all of life’s variables but having an estate plan in place takes a great deal of stress out of the unknown.
Contact the knowledgeable estate planning lawyers at Cherkowski Marsden LLP in Vernon and Salmon Arm for trusted legal advice and guidance on your estate planning needs, including how best to maximize clarity and minimize financial implications for your estate trustees and heirs. We look forward to collaborating with you to achieve your goals with respect to your interests and the protection of your loved ones. We can be reached online or by phone at 250-308-0338 (Vernon office) or 250-803-9171 (Salmon Arm office).